I’m not going to put out a Christmas CD until it’s coming out of me naturally.

The remark frames holiday music as something that should arise from genuine artistic impulse rather than market expectation. TobyMac is pushing back against the common industry pattern of releasing a “Christmas album” as a predictable career move, implying that authenticity matters more than timing or commercial opportunity. The phrase “coming out of me naturally” suggests songwriting as an organic expression of lived experience and spiritual/emotional readiness—especially relevant for an artist whose work is closely tied to personal faith. In this view, a Christmas record should be the result of sincere inspiration, not obligation, and listeners can sense the difference.